Necklace of Truth: Isn't This What Karyn Wanted?

"It's so weird. I always remembered you being a girl," Jen said. "I can't even imagine why I'd even *have* a boy as a friend." She paused. "You weren't my *boyfriend*, were you?" Karyn was speechless. Not only did Jen not remember Karyn as Karl, but she also forgot that she herself used to be a boy named Jon ... just a few minutes ago! But isn't this what Karyn wanted? In her wish, she didn't say anything about Jon retaining his memories and she knew exactly how the stone worked. So didn't she *want* Jen to forget about being Jon? "Well? Were you my boyfriend, or what?" Jen asked, when Karyn hadn't answered her.