Wait...

"Uh, by the way," said Alan, "how did you do that? Karyn transformed you already, and wishes can't be reversed... you can't be transformed into something else that doesn't match the first wish." "Hmm. I wish I knew how that happened," said Joy. "Oh, it's fine. It changed the past so that I wore a much better disguise. So I can look like the disguise and look like your dream girl too." "Yeah," said Alan. "Well, about your question, I mean... you're still Jon. I love you and all that, but..."