Athena Acquired a New Sex Organ

Athena pulled up her black dress, revealing a penis between her legs. "I ... I didn't mean to wish for one. But ..." "But, Athena. You've *always* had a penis." "What? How come you ..." But then Athena remembered the letter that accompanied the talisman. It said that anyone that didn't hear the wish thought the result of the wish had always been so. So, Zoe (and everyone else) thought that Athena always had a penis. How was that even justified? Was she some sort of a transsexual or something? And since wishes couldn't be reversed, how was she going to return to normal? "Wait a minute," Zoe said. "How did you use the talisman when I had it here? You didn't take it, did you?"